Quote:
From my (albeit limited) understanding, this might be a real benefit to the 60s and high 50s but probably nothing more than a hindrance to the lower folks (myself included). In PvP terms, we are just going to be griefed (really) and I imagine our siege contribution would be minimal (against 60+s).
To be honest, I'd be more inclined to level up in peace than get griefed by high levels where I'm really powerless to do anything.
If we war the last thing you want is to opt out.
In a War all siege rules apply, that is only 1% XP loss per death as opposed to 5-6% normally, can't drop gear as opposed to some nebulous chance to drop gear. So yes if we war you want to make sure that you ARE signed up!.
I lost 20%XP in Fahrig's last war and boy was I glad that we were engaging the enemy under those rules...
However, your question is valid and my answer to you Vil is this.
What guarantee do you have that one of the high level players in our clan won't start a shitfight over the narrowing XP areas in the game with another clan instantly propelling you into uncontrolled PvP?
I put it to you that the same guarantees will exist whether you are in an alliance or not, albeit with a greater degree of risk as we do not have direct controll over the decision making process. We do however have some input into it and there will be options.
Turning up to a siege can only occur as one of 2 options - joining the defenders or attackers. Regardless of which one you chose the other will mark you as their enemy.
It is certainly possible that we can join Revolutions, with the caveat that we will not attend sieges and turn up only for raids.
I do not know what their answer will be to this and so I will go away and get an answer on that for us all.
The final issue you raise is the one that concerns me most. The "Me" or "I" statement as the definitve for any proposed action/direction.
We need to stop thinking of the clan, as a conveniance store. Ie I browse here on a daily/weekly basis with the option to buy something.
Levelling a character is only a valid reason as long as there is something to do with it once you have arrived at that juncure. If you view your progression only from the point of view of the XP group, then why join a clan ? If you can sustain yourself happily to some self defined point, even better, but what then ?
I put it to you that life is not as black and white as we'd like to have it. There are numerous opportunities and decisions which you will have before you as you level up.
The ubiquitous feature amongst them is that of risk.
And when talking risk in this context we have to ask ourselves, what are we as individuals prepared to risk for one another and for the clan as a whole?
So whilst I understand when you say that this will be a hindrance to you, it is equally true to say that, why should we not ally which gives us opportunities to Raid, Siege, access to more high end materials and resources (due to the other clans higher levels) just because it makes a few of the lower level guys uncomfortable.
There is no certainty that you will be PvPd/Griefed more. There is just an intangible perception of this happening.
There is however the fact that one day you WILL be at the same juncture and the question is what will you say then ?
Will it be ok to do all these things in 3 months time when you feel you have sufficently levelled ? And how will you respond to those that pose the same question to you, as that which you pose to us today?
Don't misunderstand me, I'm not having a go at you I am merely using your post to illustrate the fact that this is all simply an issue of inward perception as opposed to an outward and clan opportunity/potential and growth based perception which is what is required to get ahead in L2. Its not a good or bad thing but its an issue to be discussed with an open mind.
I certainly hope that before any decisions are pushed through, we debate this as we have been till everyone has aired their concerns and that those who are driving the process provide them with answers that they can accept if not necessarily agree with.