Alienware only donate hardware if you give them a good review?

36 public posts in this discussion.

Post 1

http://www.hexus.net/content/item.php?item=7113

Wow basically they were told after giving our last PC a justifiably average review we are no longer sending you any product to test or review.

I know your thinking everyone does this.

But not everyone fully admits it in an email chain.

Pretty disturbing to think that the alienware 'mystique' is just a PR creation.

Post 2

long read but a good one.. all i can say is ... Pwned.. never put somthing in writing like that..

Post 3

Most manufacturers of any hardware pull the same strings. I've had the same problems with Everglide, Razer and Steel. None of them like me (or Pantheon) anymore, because their products aren't anything flash, and we weren't affraid to illustrate that.

Post 4

"sigh" and i quote :P

Quote:
the only inference which can be made from this is that ?Alienware? will only submit products to publications which will write nice things about ?Alienware?

That's was and remains Alienware's global marketing strategy from the beginning. We're hardly alone

is kinda stupid and very costing, to not only insult a revew webpage but to think you can control the media through a simple threat of discontinuing product samples is just plain dumb.

Post 5

ESPECIALLY WHEN THEY TAKE 4 ****ING MONTHS TO SEND YOU YOUR ORDER </rant>

forgot to mention their ****ing laptops overheat up here.. nuff said

Post 6

realistically their PC's are all smoke and mirrors for that price. I had a conversation one day with a guy who had a mindset that alienware PC's are the fastest on earth.

No doubt another marketing victim.

Post 7

I don't know, after reading the email exchange it seems that the Hexus side consists of arrogant, childish pricks.

Summary:
====================================
Email 1 - Hexus to Alienware:

We'd like for you to give us a PC for free so we can review it. We "anticipate that a G80-based Alienware machine will have massive review impact."

Email 2 - Alienware to Hexus:

Given your unfavourable review I can't send you any hardware to review, especially since my own job is at stake over that review. And seeing how you wrote that there are better and cheaper alternatives to our PCs, maybe you would be better off using those to benchmark the new card.

Besides which, we'd be stupid to give you the same unit for review that you have already written an unfavourite review for.

Email 3 - Hexus to Alienware:

If I'd known if anyone on my side was going to ask you for a product, I would have stopped it from happening, it was sent without my authority. Do you know why? Cause you spoke with my co-director on msn in which you said pretty muc hthe same thing as in the email. Your email was childish too.

I tried calling your mobile once, but you didn't pick up, so I assume you're snobbing me! You're a moron, any intelligent person would agree. You're a liability to your own company.

BTW, I'm going to publish all the emails you've written me, let's see how you like that. Oh, and I don't want to hear from you again.

Email 4: Alienware to Hexus:

That's unwarranted and offensive that you would do this and tell me I can't reply. Calling me a moron for how we deal with product placements for reviews makes no sense, because I'm the marketing manager for Alienware.

That said, you seem to be upset that it's my idea that we don't send you any more products to review, and that I said this to your co-director. That's not the case, I've spoken to him before about the constraints under which we work and have been frank with him about it. I would be very surprised if he held the same views as you.

I spent days drawing up a report justifying my decision to send you the product unit in the first place, which my superiors say they would never have done. I value Hexus and don't completely disagree with your review. I thought our previous dealings would let you know that.

Also, I didn't snob you, I wouldn't do that. I also don't understand my own company's position on giving you products to review. If you took offense to my email for some reason, then I'll take the blame since it was not intentional. I have these frank discussions with your co-director all the time, and thought I could do that with you.

Would you be able to calm down and have a rational discussion with me about this?
====================================

It appears that

a) The marketing director shouldn't have sent the original product to be reviewed in the first place, and has gotten into trouble over that.
b) The marketing director likes the reviev site, but it's not in his hands to send him another product for review.

All the personal insults appear to come from the guy representing Hexus towards Alienware.

I know Alienware PCs suck ass, but I can't say I have any sympathy for Hexus.

Post 8

Quote from dragon xr;284300:
is kinda stupid and very costing, to not only insult a revew webpage but to think you can control the media through a simple threat of discontinuing product samples is just plain dumb.

There was no threat.

It was an explanation as to why they were no longer sending them products to be reviewed. There was no option to take back there review and start saying nice things about them.

If they want to review any further Alienware products, they can obtain it themselves.

Post 9

Quote from Jaian;284318:

If they want to review any further Alienware products, they can obtain it themselves.

4 ****ING MONTHS LATER

Post 10

Quote from Aegis;284322:
4 ****ING MONTHS LATER

Which is what they should put in their review. If the service is bad, as a review site they should let their readers know that.

I don't see the point of chucking a hissy fit and personally insulting the marketing manager because Alienware won't send them free PCs to review when Alienware thinks they're going to get a negative review.

Post 11

yeah have to agree with you... and apart from the occasional overheat and the delay in getting it, this laptop really is good. Handles photoshop like it's a cheap whore, and bf2142 runs nicely at lunchtime =)

Post 12

i dont know why people are surprised. lol. a company has to protect it's image. bad reviews mean less sales.

and its not like their machines are crap...they are well built and look groovy :p

Post 13

Why do they(people's perceptions) say their pc's are built so awesomely and so fast.

Do they manufacture their own hardware from scratch? Do they overclock? Is there a reason why I couldn't build myself a pc just as fast? Do they just use the componentry that everyone else does?

I don't care if they have a shiny case with cable runs, whats the substance to their hardware apparently being so awesome?

Post 14

The funny thing is, I've heard nothing but slander about Alienware PC's and Laptops.

The bad word-of-mouth is what's kept my brain even entertaining the idea of purchasing one.

Post 15

After reading the article all I can say is the guys at Hexus seem like childish peckerheads. The only thing the guy from alienware did wrong was to put in writing what should be commonly known. Of course if a review says your product is crap, why would you send them anymore of your stuff for free? So they can bash you again?

Post 16

Quote from Frenzy;284346:
Why do they(people's perceptions) say their pc's are built so awesomely and so fast.

Do they manufacture their own hardware from scratch? Do they overclock? Is there a reason why I couldn't build myself a pc just as fast? Do they just use the componentry that everyone else does?

I don't care if they have a shiny case with cable runs, whats the substance to their hardware apparently being so awesome?

of course they dont build their own parts, apart from the cases and associated trappings. And sure, like pretty much any namebrand PC manufacturer, they do nothing you couldn't do yourselves - they cater for the lazy gamer that can't be assed/isn't up to spec enough to be able to build their own machine - they use decent parts and charge more because of that, put it in a pretty case so those people that DONT understand what's under the hood can feel good about buying one too - they can see it's different from your dells, HPs, viewmasters *snicker* etc. That's the point.

Post 17

The point i tried to make, is that is Alienwares reputation false?, we all know companies do it. The fact that the perception is that these are the fastest well built gaming machines around and have been for a while.

Who cares what the case looks like, its performance they have built their possibly dodgy reputation on.

And the line of my manager threatened my job blah blah is one of the oldest sales lines in the book :)

Post 18

what you have to remember is people and company's can get jealous of anothers success, and make all sorts of accusations and slander.

if you really want to know. ask vorly. he bought one. and as far as i know he thought it was awesome.

Post 19

It more that i actually thought Alienware was above this kind of thing I guess.

I dont see the point in a website slandering Alienware apart from being butthurt they aren't getting any new kit. Alienware have been a success for a few years so I dont think your first point is valid in this case.

But meh who knows, like i said, i thought Alienware were already streets ahead and they didnt need to do this. That was more to the point of the post :)

Post 20

If Alienware sent me free boxes of doom I'd write super nice things about them :)

Post 21

they've shat me around, my laptop overheats, but i still love it. speeeeeeeeeedy - of course my judgement is coloured by the 6year old dell laptop I offloaded to get this one.

Post 22

no company is ever over this sort of thing...no matter how they act...or seem to.

Post 23

there's a difference between writing a good review for someone, and atleast being diplomatic about calling their product shit.

if you're not prepared to jeopardise your reputation to do the latter, it's pretty stupid to assume people are going to keep investing in your opinion.

Post 24

I didn't see the part in the review where they called it shit, they just said there were two better machines out there for the price?

Can you link it?

Post 25

neither have I, but surely if you know the product's inferior, you'd set about highlighting every possible positive aspect you could find.. not comparing the downfalls against the competitors ;)

Post 26

Quote from doyen;284525:
neither have I, but surely if you know the product's inferior, you'd set about highlighting every possible positive aspect you could find.. not comparing the downfalls against the competitors ;)

No i wouldn't, that wouldn't be an honest review would it?

So your saying when doing reviews, ignore the rubbish and just talk about the good points?

Post 27

Quote from doyen;284523:
if you're not prepared to jeopardise your reputation to do the latter, it's pretty stupid to assume people are going to keep investing in your opinion.
ahuh

edit: if your intentions are that you expect them to keep sending you free products. they're essentially trying to buy your goodwill.

Post 28

Did you even read the article mate or just talking in general here?

They didn't call the product shit, they pointed out a few better machines.
And for that Alienware pulled the review deal.

So i'm still failing to see your point as relevent to this article?

Post 29

yes, I read the article. I also read the snippets of the emails jaian posted.
you didn't post the review of the product itself, you posted the opinion of the reviewers.

so yeh, I'm generalising. what did they expect would happen?

Post 30

Well the links to the review were on the actual main link itself and yeah I read them and didnt see anything too bad there.
Jaians snippets were a bit cut & pasted.

Im just surprised that you think that this is ok :)

I used to run the HH stores for years and had everyone from EA/Sony/Manacomm/MS/ hounding me continually to push their crap out regardless of what I had said/sold of their product before, and this is when we were the only game in town.

Things change I suppose if this is now the norm :)

Post 31

I'm not saying it's ok. I'm saying it's to be expected.

I've worked pretty closely with sales and marketing departments for quite a few different companies LG/Nokia/Optus/Vodafone, and from a service perspective, it's not uncommon to find yourself dealing with problems about people that have been told something creative about what a product can do that it can't.

That's marketing. That's the nature of the beast. I just, I dunno, I don't get the argument. You accept goods, freely, from a company expecting you to write rave reviews about their product. Then you get suprised when they no longer want to invest that capital because your reviews weren't favourable?

Either you have a good product, and expect to get rave reviews. Or you don't have a good product, and expect that your purchasing that reviewers good will by giving them free stuff. There's only really two outcomes to the situation. It's good, so you use them again, or it isn't good. So you don't.

Post 32

When I read a review, I expect it to be unbiased and give me info to make an informed choice on ALL aspects of the product.
On the other hand, if I want to hear the biased marketing hype, I'll get my info from the company itself, who will be talking themselves up and saying their product is the best on market regardless. I give little credibility to someone who states how great they are.

Post 33

Fair enough

I always thought there was a 3rd option but I havent been in sales for close to 10 years now and I suppose there are a million websites/reviews out there.

My experience with these issues was you told the company their product was shit and they would start to send you even MORE stuff to change your mind.

But as stated above that was probably a unique situation being the only store in the NT for 3-4 years before the others opened up.

Post 34

Quote from Frenzy;284546:
When I read a review, I expect it to be unbiased and give me info to make an informed choice on ALL aspects of the product.
On the other hand, if I want to hear the biased marketing hype, I'll get my info from the company itself, who will be talking themselves up and saying their product is the best on market regardless. I give little credibility to someone who states how great they are.
personally, I don't do either. I don't listen to the sales dude on the shop floor any more than I assume there's value in random internet reviews.

I'm more inclined to look at the product's specs, make sure that they meet my needs - and then go hunting for 'support' forums to find out whether there's any whinge threads. Because you're almost guaranteed if there's a problem, people will be complaining about it.

Post 35

Quote from Frenzy;284546:
When I read a review, I expect it to be unbiased and give me info to make an informed choice on ALL aspects of the product.

doesnt really exisist. this is the internet remember.

Post 36

Quote from Frenzy;284546:
When I read a review, I expect it to be unbiased and give me info to make an informed choice on ALL aspects of the product.

TANSTAAFL. If you want an "unbiased" review, you want to find a site which poses as Joe Everygamer and buys it online with a credit card, then rings up with tech support questions. I understand a few of the sites do it.

But not a few are just a clever way of trying to swing some free schwag. This guy is a moron for thinking he's somehow above that, or that he's made some astonishing discovery ("People won't reward me with nice stuff when I shit on them! IT'S A CONSPIRAMACY!!1!")