Duron/Athlon/P3.. That is the question

5 public posts in this discussion.

Post 1

Just looking for a general concensus of which everyone thinks is better.. of course athlon rule the world but im thinking of buying a new processor and would be interested to NOT make a stupid decision. So everyone please have ya say.. *ps.. only the people that know what they're talking about i dont want a dribbler to respond* =P

Post 2

I agree with R3, Intel is slowly dying, but who knows what the P4 (Willamite) will be like. However, AMD's main concern is compatability. They are getting better, but Intel is still better in those regards. If you can find a good WORKING combination that includes an AMD chip then go for it.

Gary Jukes
Gazza[AGQx]

Post 3

Forget the P3, Intel are also making a new proccessor, its the P4 but with some fancy name. I forget what it is now, but anyways =P

But screw that anyways, ive got a P3, and my new proccessor aint gonna be intel, AMD all the way.

So, its Duron VS Thunderbird
The TB is basically the next thingy-ma-bob in the Athlon generation, there is no mistaking its gonna be great. But, the Duron is actually better for the hardcore gamer. Easier over-clocking, and performace in games un-matched by any other proccessor. It's gonna be my choice for mah new comp...

Post 4

At the moment there are really these chips competing.

Athlon (series 1) Slot A, Socket A (and others)
Athlon TBird (series 2) Slot A, Socket A (Not many Slot A's and only up to a certain rating)
Athlon Duron

PIII Katmai
PIII CuMine series

There are a couple of others.

Processors in the works:

P4 (refered to as Itanium at Intel)
Sledge Hammer (New processor in development by AMD)

First things first. The P4, and SH are both 64 bit processors. In regards to gaming performance, you can ask anyone, and they can tell you without having to think twice about it, the P4 WILL NOT run games faster then a PIII. P4 is being released as a Server Solution at first, and hasn't been designed to cope with instruction sets under 32 bits, and even then 32 bit is very hard to maintain.
The Sledge Hammer however is still uncertain so don't let anybody tell you that it'll be much better then the Athlon.
In regards to waiting for one. I'd say stuff it. Unless of course you can wait for another year or so for the P4 and longer for the SH. -_-

If you currently own an Intel chipset, and DON'T want to upgrade your motherboard then you'll have to go with another Intel.

Likewise with AMD.

As to which is better.

The Athlon T-Bird series does kick the PIII CuMine in regards to performance, there's no doubting that. The series one Athlon doesn't however. It performs ever so slightly slower. Not that a couple of bit here and there will make too much difference.

The Duron however is completely different. Imagine buying a chip running at 650mhz for the same price as a celeron running at the same speed, yet with the power of a PIII!?
Not only that, but the Duron is seriously overclockable.
This is why I'd choose a Duron over a PIII any day. Why buy a PIII that can maybe overclock about 250 mhz with extreem cooling, when you can get yourself a duron that overclocks past 1ghz with the same amount of cooling?

Anyway, that's my opinion. In summary. The Athlon is the way to go. YOu can overclock the current models (high end mind you) to over 1.5 ghz, and keep it stable. The CuMine PIII can only go to 1.05 with it's current cache system. -_-

The duron even overclocks higher then that.

Post 5

hahahahah I got a p2 333 celaron ahahha beat that hahahahah